Monday, November 01, 2010

Telangana 66: Notes

On People’s Revolution

There’s a definition for ‘revolution’. 

Revolution means that an exploited population must take desperate measures against great odds to overthrow its oppressors. 
-          Marvin Harris

Let’s understand this in Telanganas context. The ‘exploited people’ are Telanganas.  The ‘oppressors’ are Seemandhras, more specifically Andhras.  The ‘great odds’ are stacked against Telanganas, as we can see from the recent political maneuvers that creation of Telangana was initially impossible, and even now not a distinct possibility.  Back in 1990s when I talked about separate Telangana, most friends, from the state of Andhra Pradesh or other parts of India called it a pipe dream - impossibility.  Even now it is not assured that state of Telangana will be created, and therefore the exploited people continue to fight.   The people of Telangana resort to ‘desperate measures’, which invariably include denouncing and defying the authority, which happens to be the Government of Andhra Pradesh, under the control of the ‘oppressors’.  People of Telangana go about protesting, destroying or attacking the symbols of authority, the symbols of oppressors, and defying the rules and laws imposed onto them. 
On Gaddar

Gaddar, a ballad singer, who inspired millions of Telanganas with his songs, a strong supporter of creation of Telangana, has recently announced the creation of a new front called, Telangana Praja Front (TPF).  Whether they should contest elections or not is still a matter of debate within the members of the party, but it is clear that this front is another addition to a number of organizations and outfits created to accelerate the formation of Telangana. 

Some people from Telangana felt that this new entrant will dilute the absolute majority that TRS, Telangana Praja Samiti, has enjoyed in the recent elections.  They believe that the vote will be distributed between the two outfits and hence the cause of Telangana will be diluted in the eyes of its opponents. 

There is always this dilemma in all people’s revolutions.  Should we put up a united front under one banner or shall we have multiple banners representing the same cause?  We can easily see why there is a debate and why there is no single answer to this question.    Putting up a single united front has its obvious advantages.   It will mobilize the entire population under one banner and therefore will sound effective.  It will create a powerful group and hence will be in a strong position to negotiate with the power brokers and opponents to win the cause.

But then there is a danger to the future if there is only one legitimate liberator because that could lead to suppression of all dissenting voices once the revolution has succeeded.  There is a danger that not all peoples and groups are well-represented in that single outfit.  What will happen to their future once the revolution succeeds?

Here, we need to understand that a grand people’s revolution, like India’s Independence Movement or Telangana Movement, is not always against one single master.   Indians went about toppling many masters in addition to the British in their struggle for Independence.  They had to fight the Indian monarchs and autocrats, the feudal lords, the caste oppression, the male dominated family structure, and many others, in addition to fighting the British.   They created a revolution that brought social and political change beyond what would have been achieved if it was just kicking British out. 

Telangana also needs a revolution like that.  And for that to happen, we need to take care of many fights, topple many masters, many of them are internal, and to do that, one single outfit may not be enough.   Therefore, we need to welcome Gaddar and his political outfit for what it represents. 

AP formation Day on Nov 1

On 1st November, 1956, the State of Andhra Pradesh was formed my merging two regions, that of Telangana and Andhra State.   This day is now declared as the day of betrayal.  Telangana joined the state reluctantly only after certain conditions were agreed upon in ‘Gentlemen’s Agreement’.  Now, that most of those promises stand broken, now that people of Telangana have filed for divorce which is being examined by Srikrishna Committee, people of Telangana have decided not to celebrate this day.  Instead they would like to oppose the celebrations which are being mandated by the government of Andhra Pradesh which is ruled by the majority Seemandhras. 

7 comments:

  1. Yes, it is funny to celebrate marriage day when the divorce case is in court.

    It is even funnier that few seemandra leaders saying if we dont celebrate that means we are dis-respecting our former leaders like burgula etc.

    After 5 years of marriage my husband turned out bad and I filed a case for divorce in court, next sunday it is my marriage day and as per seemandra logic I should still celebrate my marriage day otherwise if I dont celebrate that means I am dis-respecting my parents. How stupid....

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, it is funny to celebrate marriage day when the divorce case is in court.

    It is even funnier that few seemandra leaders saying if we dont celebrate that means we are dis-respecting our former leaders like burgula etc.

    After 5 years of marriage my husband turned out bad and I filed a case for divorce in court, next sunday it is my marriage day and as per seemandra logic I should still celebrate my marriage day otherwise if I dont celebrate that means I am dis-respecting my parents. How stupid....

    ReplyDelete
  3. Agreed with your argument GreenStar.

    But what if your Husband wants to celebrate it. He has full right isn't it. You don't go or celebrate and that's fine too.

    And what if some of your relatives also want to come. Will you stop them? Or break their heads. Or what if your parents want to come?

    Now you know who's stupid.

    ReplyDelete
  4. kancha Iliah in his article in today's paper appears to state that the 'dalits' and 'bahujans' of T don't want a separate state.

    ReplyDelete
  5. But what if your Husband wants to celebrate it. He has full right isn't it. You don't go or celebrate and that's fine too.

    Husband can celebrate but that is not a good way to fix there marriage when wife don't want to celebrate. Husband can celebrate in his bedroom but not in wifes bedroom. If you do not forcefully celebrate Nov-1 in Telangana area then that is fine. And husband should not force wife to involve in celebrations by saying if she dont involve that means she has no respect to her parents.

    ReplyDelete
  6. POK, please read the article again. Dr. Kancha Iliah (the BC activist) described two approaches behind small states. He only criticized the "Hindutva approach".

    Dr. Ilaiah himself supports Telangana (though with some conditions). In fact, most dalit leaders even in Andhra (excepting Prof. Samuel who is Ambati Rambabu's right hand man) either support Telangana or are neutral.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Though OU students get max media attention , the Vanguard of the agitation will be SC and ST people in Rural areas in RR ,Nalgonda Districst along Andhra Border.

    Today OU students could not breach Police to reach their objective of Gunpark. But people in Nalgonda successfully blocked NH9 for some hours cutting off links between Hyd and Vijayawada.

    Few Platoons of Police may be able to control Irate Students, but it is tactically impossible to Gaurd thousands of KMS of Highways. In the event of "blocade" of Highways even for few days, the losses to Industry will be in Thousands of Crores and the govt will have to Succumb to the Pressure.

    ReplyDelete

Dear Commenters:
Please identify yourself. At least use a pseudonym. Otherwise there will be too many *Anonymous*; making it confusing.

Do NOT write personal information or whereabouts about the author or other commenters. You are free to write about yourself. Please do not use abusive language. Do not indulge in personal attacks and insults.

Write comments which are relevant and make sense so that the debate remains healthy.